Education · 9 min read

Questions to Ask a Gold IRA Company Before You Sign

A plain checklist of questions to put to any Gold IRA company about fees, pricing, buyback terms, minimums and custody, so you can compare answers side by side before you commit.

By Adam Zimmerman, Owner of Syl-Lee Antiques & Author of Antique Help

Most Gold IRA companies start with a phone call. The person on the other end has done that call many times. You may be doing it for the first time. A short list of questions evens that out.

This guide gives you that list. It does not tell you which company to choose. It helps you collect the same facts from each one, so you can compare them on the details that matter to you.

A quick note before you start: we are a reader-supported site, and we may be paid by some of the companies we feature. That can influence which companies appear and where. The questions below work just as well on those companies as on any other.

Before the call

A little preparation makes the answers easier to compare. Decide roughly how much you are considering moving and from which kind of account, such as a 401(k) or an existing IRA (individual retirement account). Have a notepad ready, and plan to ask for anything important to be confirmed by email.

It also helps to know the three parties involved. The dealer sells you the metal. The custodian is the IRS-approved firm that holds the account on paper. The depository is the facility that physically stores the metal. One company may arrange all three, but they are usually separate businesses with separate fees.

Questions about fees

Gold IRA costs come in layers. Ask for each one by name, and ask whether it is a flat amount or a percentage. Our guide to Gold IRA fees explains each layer in more detail.

  • What is the one-time account setup fee, and who charges it?
  • What is the annual custodian fee?
  • What is the annual storage fee, and is it flat or based on the value of the metal?
  • Is there a fee to close the account or transfer it elsewhere?
  • Are any fees waived in the first year, and what do they become after that?
  • Can you send me a full written fee schedule?

Questions about pricing and the spread

The spot price is the market price for raw metal at a given moment. You will pay more than spot. The difference is the premium. The spread is the gap between what the company charges you to buy a coin and what it would pay you to buy it back. Together, these are often the largest cost of a Gold IRA, and they are not always listed with the fees.

  • What is the premium over spot on the specific products you are suggesting, as a percentage?
  • What would you pay me to buy back the same product today?
  • Why are you suggesting these products rather than common bullion coins or bars?
  • When is my price locked, and what happens if spot moves before then?

Questions about buyback and selling

At some point you may want to sell metal or take withdrawals. It is worth knowing how that works before you buy.

  • Do you buy back metal from clients, and is that in writing?
  • How is the buyback price set?
  • How long does a sale usually take from request to cash in the account?
  • Am I free to sell to a different dealer if I choose?

Questions about minimums and the transfer

Many companies set a minimum account size. Moving money in is usually done by rollover or transfer, and the way it is handled can affect taxes. Our guides cover rollovers step by step.

  • What is your minimum investment?
  • Will this be a direct transfer between custodians, or will funds pass through my hands?
  • Who handles the paperwork, and how long does it usually take?
  • What happens if the transfer is delayed or rejected?

Questions about storage and custody

Metal in a Gold IRA has to be held by an approved depository, not at home. Ask where yours will be and on what terms.

  • Which custodian and which depository will hold my account and metal?
  • Is storage segregated (my own specific items) or commingled (pooled with other clients' metal of the same type)?
  • How is the metal insured, and by whom?
  • How often will I receive statements, and what do they show?

Questions about estate planning and downsizing

A Gold IRA may outlast your working years, so it helps to ask how it fits into later plans, such as leaving the account to family or reducing your holdings over time.

One point many people do not expect: an IRA usually passes to whoever is named on its beneficiary form, not to whoever is named in your will. A beneficiary is the person or people you choose to receive the account after your death. If the form and the will say different things, the form generally decides. Keeping it up to date matters.

Downsizing works differently with metal than with cash. You can usually sell metal inside the account, or take the coins or bars out as an in-kind distribution, which means receiving the metal itself rather than its cash value. Either can have tax effects, so ask how each one works before you rely on it.

  • How do I name or change a beneficiary, and can I name more than one?
  • What does the process look like for my family if they inherit the account?
  • Can a beneficiary keep the metal, or must it be sold?
  • If I want to reduce my holdings, can I sell part of the metal, and how is it priced?
  • Do you offer in-kind distributions, and what fees or shipping costs apply?
  • Who do my family contact, and what documents will they need?

Signs worth noticing

How a company answers can tell you as much as what it says. These are not proof of a problem, but they are worth weighing:

  • Reluctance to put fees or buyback terms in writing.
  • Pressure to decide on the call, or offers that expire within days.
  • Steering toward collectible or proof coins with high premiums, without explaining why.
  • Strong claims about where the economy or gold prices are heading.
  • Free metal or bonus offers without a clear explanation of what they cost elsewhere.

Comparing the answers

Once you have answers from two or three companies, put them side by side. Look at total first-year cost, ongoing yearly cost, the spread on the same products, and how clearly each company answered.

Our side-by-side comparison and provider profiles can give you a starting point. Treat them as one source among several, and check anything important with the company directly.

A note on scope

This guide is general education. It is not financial, tax or legal advice, and it does not assess whether a Gold IRA suits your situation. Rules for inherited accounts and withdrawals depend on who inherits, their age and when they inherit. For decisions about your own retirement savings or estate, a licensed financial or tax professional or an estate attorney can look at your full circumstances.

About the author

Adam Zimmerman is the owner of Syl-Lee Antiques in Manhattan and the author of Antique Help. He has spent his career valuing estates — precious metals, art and jewelry — at kitchen tables across New York. The opinions on this site are his own.

Ready for the next step?

See how we compare the companies, or read our review of Augusta Precious Metals.

Educational content only — we are not financial, legal, or tax advisors.